Choosing the right paint can be a daunting task, especially with so many high-quality brands vying for your attention. Two names consistently top the list: Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams. Both offer a wide range of products, from budget-friendly options to premium lines boasting exceptional durability and color richness. But which brand reigns supreme? This in-depth comparison will help you decide which paint best suits your needs and budget.
Benjamin Moore: The Luxury Choice
Benjamin Moore has cultivated a reputation for luxurious finishes and superior quality. Their paints are often praised for their vibrant colors, smooth application, and exceptional durability. Many consider Benjamin Moore the gold standard, willing to pay a premium for the perceived superior quality.
What Makes Benjamin Moore Unique?
- Aura® Exterior: Known for its exceptional durability and mildew resistance, Aura Exterior is a top performer for exterior projects. Its self-priming capabilities often reduce the overall painting time.
- Aura® Interior: A premium interior paint, Aura boasts excellent coverage, a luxurious sheen, and exceptional washability, making it ideal for high-traffic areas.
- Regal® Select: A popular choice that balances quality and price, offering a durable and washable finish at a slightly more affordable price point than Aura.
Sherwin-Williams: A Versatile Contender
Sherwin-Williams is a more widely accessible brand, offering a vast selection of paints catering to various budgets and projects. While often seen as slightly less luxurious than Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams consistently delivers high-quality products with competitive pricing.
Sherwin-Williams' Strengths:
- Emerald® Exterior: A strong competitor to Benjamin Moore's Aura Exterior, Emerald offers excellent durability, mildew resistance, and color retention.
- Emerald® Interior: A premium interior paint known for its smooth finish, excellent coverage, and exceptional washability. It often receives high praise for its ease of application.
- SuperPaint®: A versatile and popular choice for both interior and exterior projects, offering good quality at a more affordable price than the premium lines.
Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: Key Differences
| Feature | Benjamin Moore | Sherwin-Williams |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Generally more expensive | Generally more affordable |
| Availability | Less widely available | More widely available |
| Color Selection | Extensive, known for unique and sophisticated colors | Equally extensive, with a broad range of options |
| Durability | Often praised for exceptional durability | Offers high-quality durable options |
| Coverage | Excellent | Excellent |
| Application | Often praised for smooth application | Generally smooth application |
Which Brand is Right for You?
The "better" brand depends entirely on your individual needs and priorities.
-
Choose Benjamin Moore if: You prioritize top-of-the-line quality, a luxurious finish, and are willing to pay a premium for superior performance and unique color options. The slightly higher price often reflects a longer-lasting, higher-quality finish.
-
Choose Sherwin-Williams if: You're seeking a balance between quality and affordability, need wider availability, or prefer a broader range of price points to fit your budget. Sherwin-Williams offers excellent quality at various price points.
How Much Does Each Brand Cost?
Pricing varies greatly depending on the specific paint line, location, and retailer. Generally, Benjamin Moore is positioned at a higher price point than Sherwin-Williams. However, both brands offer a spectrum of options, from budget-friendly to premium choices. It's best to obtain quotes from local paint retailers for accurate pricing.
What is the Difference in Coverage?
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paints offer excellent coverage. However, the actual coverage may vary depending on the specific paint line, surface preparation, and the number of coats applied. Always refer to the manufacturer's recommendations for optimal coverage.
Which Paint Lasts Longer?
Both brands offer paints with exceptional durability. Factors such as proper surface preparation, the number of coats applied, and environmental conditions will significantly influence the longevity of the paint. While anecdotal evidence often suggests Benjamin Moore may last slightly longer, in practice, both brands offer long-lasting options when applied correctly.
Which Paint is Easier to Apply?
Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams paints are generally considered easy to apply. The specific ease of application can depend on the chosen paint line and personal preference. Many painters find both brands to provide a smooth, even finish.
Ultimately, the best way to decide is to consider your budget, project needs, and desired level of quality. Sampling both brands' paints on a small area is highly recommended to compare their colors and finishes firsthand before committing to a large project.
