What Questions Are Asked on a Police Polygraph? Understanding the Process
Polygraph tests, often called "lie detector" tests, are used by law enforcement as one tool in investigations. While not admissible as evidence in many courts, they can influence investigative direction and even plea bargaining. The questions asked during a police polygraph are carefully constructed and fall into several categories. Understanding these categories can help clarify the process.
The Structure of a Polygraph Exam: Before diving into the types of questions, it's important to note the process usually involves three phases:
-
Pre-test Interview: This crucial stage establishes rapport between the examiner and the subject. The examiner gathers information about the case and the subject's background. They also explain the procedure and answer any questions the subject may have. This is where the examiner assesses the subject's demeanor and baseline physiological responses.
-
The Test: This involves attaching sensors to measure physiological responses like heart rate, respiration, blood pressure, and perspiration. The examiner then asks a series of questions, categorized as follows:
-
Post-test Interview: After the test, the examiner analyzes the results and discusses them with the subject. This interview is crucial for clarification and often involves reviewing the responses and explaining the interpretation of the data.
Types of Questions Asked During a Polygraph Test:
1. Irrelevant Questions: These are neutral questions designed to establish a baseline of physiological responses. Examples:
- "Is your name [Subject's Name]?"
- "Is today Tuesday?"
- "Were you born in [Subject's City]?"
These questions help the examiner determine a "normal" physiological response for the individual. Deviations from this baseline are then compared to responses to relevant and control questions.
2. Relevant Questions: These directly relate to the crime under investigation. Examples:
- "Did you kill [Victim's Name]?"
- "Did you steal the money from the bank?"
- "Were you present at the scene of the robbery?"
These are the core questions the examiner is most interested in. The subject's responses to these questions are compared against their baseline and control questions to determine deception.
3. Control Questions: These are designed to elicit a deceptive response, even if the subject is telling the truth. They are broader and relate to past behaviors. Examples:
- "Before the age of 25, did you ever do anything you are ashamed of?"
- "Have you ever told a lie to get out of trouble?"
- "Have you ever taken something that didn't belong to you?"
The examiner's hypothesis is that a guilty person will show more physiological stress in response to relevant questions, while an innocent person will show more stress to control questions. This is a key element of the controversial logic behind the polygraph.
How Are the Questions Presented?
Questions are often presented in a mixed order. The examiner might repeat relevant questions multiple times in various contexts. The entire process is designed to be somewhat unpredictable to maximize the chances of detecting deception.
What if the Polygraph Results are Inconclusive?
It's essential to understand that polygraph results are not always conclusive. Factors like stress, anxiety, medication, and the subject's familiarity with countermeasures can influence the results. Inconclusive results are not uncommon, and they don't necessarily indicate guilt or innocence.
Are Polygraph Tests Admissible in Court?
The admissibility of polygraph results varies widely depending on jurisdiction and specific circumstances. In many places, they are not admissible as evidence, primarily due to concerns about the test's scientific validity and potential for manipulation.
Are there different types of polygraph tests?
Yes, there are variations in techniques and question formats used in polygraph testing. While the basic principles remain consistent, specific approaches may differ between examiners and agencies.
In conclusion, the questions asked on a police polygraph are strategically designed to elicit physiological responses that can be interpreted (with varying degrees of reliability) as indicators of truthfulness or deception. Understanding the types of questions involved and the limitations of the test is crucial to interpreting any results or accusations that may arise. The polygraph is a complex tool with significant limitations that should be viewed within the context of the broader investigation.
