Why I Quit the SCA: A Personal Reflection on Leaving the Society for Creative Anachronism
The Society for Creative Anachronism (SCA) is a vibrant community built on the passion for recreating the arts and skills of pre-17th-century Europe. For many, it’s a lifelong commitment, a second family. However, leaving the SCA, for whatever reason, is a deeply personal experience. This article explores some common reasons people choose to depart, offering insights and perspectives based on my own experiences and those shared by others within the community.
Why did I quit the SCA? This is a question I asked myself many times. There wasn't a single, dramatic event, but rather a confluence of factors. Ultimately, it came down to a shift in priorities and a reevaluation of my time commitments. My personal circumstances changed, and the SCA, while still enjoyable, no longer fit comfortably within my life's evolving structure.
What are the common reasons people leave the SCA?
This is often a multifaceted question, with answers varying greatly from person to person. However, several recurring themes emerge:
1. Time Commitment: The SCA demands a considerable time investment. From crafting and sewing to attending events, practices, and meetings, it can be a significant undertaking. As life changes – new jobs, family responsibilities, or other commitments – maintaining this level of participation becomes increasingly difficult. This was a significant factor in my own decision.
2. Internal Politics and Drama: Like any large organization, the SCA has its share of interpersonal conflicts and internal politics. These can be draining and discouraging, sometimes leading members to withdraw. The intensity of these dynamics varies from kingdom to kingdom and even from group to group within a kingdom, but the potential for interpersonal conflict is a reality.
3. Lack of Personal Growth or Fulfillment: For some, the SCA may no longer provide the personal enrichment they once sought. Perhaps their interests have shifted, or they’ve reached a plateau in their skill development. The sense of not progressing or feeling stagnant can be a reason to leave.
4. Financial Strain: Participation in the SCA can be expensive. The cost of crafting supplies, event fees, and travel can add up quickly. Financial pressures can make it difficult to sustain involvement, leading some to re-evaluate their priorities.
5. Lack of Welcoming Atmosphere: While the SCA strives to be inclusive, unfortunately, some individuals may encounter unwelcoming or even hostile behavior. Experiencing a lack of support or feeling unwelcome can lead members to leave. This is a serious concern and one that the community continuously works to address.
6. Burnout: The sheer dedication and energy required to fully participate in the SCA can lead to burnout. The constant crafting, event attendance, and social interactions can take their toll, leading individuals to seek a break or to leave entirely.
Is it hard to leave the SCA?
Yes, leaving the SCA can be emotionally challenging. Many members develop strong bonds and friendships within the community. Saying goodbye to these connections can be difficult, regardless of the reasons behind the departure. The sense of loss is often profound, as the SCA becomes a significant part of many people's lives.
Can I come back to the SCA after leaving?
Absolutely! The SCA welcomes returning members. Many individuals take breaks from active participation and return later with renewed enthusiasm. The SCA is ultimately a community built on shared interests and passion, and there's always room for those who wish to rejoin.
Leaving the SCA isn't necessarily a negative experience. It's often a reflection of personal growth and changing life circumstances. It’s a testament to individual evolution and the recognition that even the most enriching communities may not always align with our ever-changing needs and aspirations. My time in the SCA holds many cherished memories, and while I've moved on, I remain appreciative of the experiences and friendships it provided.
